Posted 23 April 2008 - 01:56 PM
I'm a 360 fan, but thats mainly because I've always been antiplaystation. As has been noted before, the xbox has a better library. Whether this will remain the case is up to your opinion on the upcoming titles.
I do not have a high definition television, so it doesn't really matter which optical drive is in use and what format movie the console can play. Unless you have a sweet HD tv (or plan to get one in the future) don't worry endlessly about this selling point.
I play online somewhat frequently, for the most part xboxlive is quite impressive. Most of the retards are still playing Halo 2 and Halo 3 and lack the time or cognitive capacity to play other games. I frequently play Chromehounds and CoD4. GoW online is fun, but it doesn't have a whole lot of replay value (at least for me).
Regarding the rrod, it seems to be pretty hit or miss. I've never had the problem, although a friend of mine has. With the no questions asked warranties and the like, why not get a 360. If it dies, well, you don't have it for a little while and then you get a brand spankin new one. Talk about support. If you bother to mess around with customer service (don't) then you might have a headache. Just buy the instant replacement warranty and you're good to go.
the PS3 is a very impressive system, I have played them and have been impressed. However, lacking any previous playstation or playstation 2 games... the backward compatibility lacks use for me. Likewise, because I have not ever owned a playstastion - I have no allegiance to a particular game (MGS).
If you just plan to play for recreation... the basic ps3 or xbox will suffice. If you want to play online, I'd go with the 360. If you want to be able to play a giant library of games, get the 60-80 gig ps3. If you want to have a system that most of your friends will be familiar with, get the 360. It all comes down to what you plan to do with it, how much cash you have to drop, and whether you have an opinion on blueray vs hd.